Rear Guards Are Required. Side Guards Are Not.
The single most important fact about underride protection is a distinction most coverage blurs. The rear of a trailer is regulated. The sides are not. 49 CFR 571.224, Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 224, establishes requirements for the installation of rear impact guards on trailers and semitrailers with a gross vehicle weight rating of 4,536 kilograms or more, roughly 10,000 pounds, and states its purpose as reducing the number of deaths and serious injuries occurring when light duty vehicles impact the rear of such trailers. A companion standard, 49 CFR 571.223, Standard No. 223, specifies the requirements for the guards themselves. Both are worth checking against a particular trailer, because Standard No. 224 excludes pole trailers, pulpwood trailers, low chassis vehicles, road construction controlled horizontal discharge trailers, special purpose vehicles, wheels back vehicles and temporary living quarters.
For the sides there is nothing. NHTSA said so in plain words in a Federal Register notice on April 1, 2025: currently, a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard requiring side underride guards on semi-trailers does not exist. That is the state of the law as this is written, and everything below follows from it.
What Is an Underride Crash?
A fully loaded tractor trailer sits high off the ground. When a smaller vehicle strikes the rear or the side of a trailer, the car can slide underneath instead of crashing into a solid surface. The trailer then strikes the car at windshield height, which is why underride crashes are so often fatal. Underride guards are steel barriers designed to stop a car from sliding under and to make the trailer absorb the impact the way an ordinary collision would.
Federal law has long required a guard on the rear of most trailers, and the requirement was strengthened recently rather than left alone. NHTSA published a final rule on July 15, 2022, effective January 11, 2023, upgrading the rear impact guard standards so that guards must provide sufficient strength and energy absorption to protect occupants of compact and subcompact passenger cars impacting the rear of trailers at 56 kilometers per hour, which is 35 miles per hour. Safety advocates asked for more. Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety, the Truck Safety Coalition and others petitioned for reconsideration, seeking protection in crashes where only 30 percent of the car’s width overlaps the rear of the trailer, and on June 27, 2024 NHTSA denied that request, concluding that the proposed standard would not be reasonable or practicable and would not meet the requirements of federal motor vehicle safety law. So the rear guard rule was tightened, then held where it is, and the sides were never covered at all.
The Sides of Trucks Are Still Unprotected
The agency has studied the question. On April 21, 2023 NHTSA published an advance notice of proposed rulemaking on side underride guards, responding to section 23011(c) of the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, which directed the Secretary of Transportation to complete additional research on side underride guards to better understand their overall effectiveness. In its preliminary analysis, NHTSA estimated that 17.2 lives would be saved and 69 serious injuries prevented annually once all trailers in the fleet were equipped, against a total discounted annual cost estimated to range between $970 million and $1.2 billion at 3 and 7 percent discount rates. The agency also noted that a side underride guard adds 450 to 800 pounds to a trailer depending on the configuration, which is the industry’s practical objection: weight added is payload lost.
The same notice contains an admission that undercuts its own arithmetic. NHTSA estimated that the actual number of fatalities associated with side underride was 78 percent higher than the number reported in the Fatality Analysis Reporting System. In other words the agency believes the official count understates the problem by more than three quarters, and its benefit estimate is built on the official count.
Independent researchers put the number far higher. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety told NHTSA in a regulatory comment that the agency’s projection is a dramatic underestimate, and IIHS Senior Research Engineer Matthew Brumbelow projected that a side underride guard mandate could prevent 159 to 217 passenger vehicle occupant fatalities per year, depending on whether protection were required only forward of the rear axle or along the full length of the trailer. IIHS also reports that aftermarket side underride guards can prevent vehicles from sliding underneath trailers at speeds as high as 40 miles per hour, and that they may work at higher speeds still, especially in crashes that are not perpendicular. The gap between 17 and 159 is not a rounding difference. It is a methodological argument about which crashes get counted.
As of April 2025, NHTSA’s Office of Rulemaking was still reviewing over 2,000 comments received on the 2023 notice. No standard has issued. That means the sides of most trailers on Interstate 65 and Interstate 24 today have no underride protection at all.
When Regulators Won’t Act, Juries Sometimes Do
Courts are the third branch of government, and they can drive safety change that Congress and regulators will not. Personal injury cases are usually built on negligence. A trucking company and a trailer manufacturer owe the public a duty to use reasonably safe equipment. Kentucky puts a version of that duty in the traffic code: under KRS 189.020, every vehicle on a highway shall be so equipped as to make a minimum of nuisance, to protect the rights of other traffic, and to promote the public safety. When a defendant fails that duty and someone is killed or badly hurt, a jury can hold it responsible and order it to pay damages.
That is not just theory. A Missouri jury returned a very large verdict against a trailer manufacturer in a fatal rear underride case in 2024. What happened to that verdict afterward is a longer and more instructive story than the headline number, and we tell it in full, including the court’s later reduction of the punitive award and the eventual resolution of the case, in our article on the underride verdict against a trailer manufacturer. We do not quote other people’s verdicts as a measure of what any case is worth, and no lawyer can promise you an outcome.
The regulatory record shows the same dynamic from the other direction. NHTSA states that the 2022 rear guard upgrade was prompted by petitions, and the side guard notice responds both to a congressional directive and to a petition for rulemaking from outside the agency. Pressure from outside has moved these rules before.
Who Can Be Held Responsible After an Underride Crash?
More than one party may share fault. Depending on the facts, responsibility can fall on the trucking company that operated an unsafe trailer, the manufacturer that designed or built a defective guard, a maintenance provider that let a guard corrode or bend without repair, or another driver whose negligence caused the collision. The maintenance path has a federal duty attached: under 49 CFR 396.3, every motor carrier must systematically inspect, repair and maintain all vehicles subject to its control, must keep a record of inspections, repairs and maintenance showing their date and nature, and must retain that record for one year where the vehicle is housed plus six months after the vehicle leaves its control. A guard that failed in a crash is either in that file or conspicuously absent from it.
Because these cases combine product defect and negligence theories, they require early investigation and preservation of the trailer and its guard as physical evidence. Our overview of truck accidents explains how Kentucky builds these claims, and a fatal crash may support a wrongful death claim for the family.
Kentucky divides fault rather than assigning all of it to one defendant, and in a case with a carrier, a manufacturer and a maintenance provider that rule decides how much gets recovered. Under KRS 411.182(1) and (2) the fact finder assigns a percentage of the total fault to each party, weighing both the nature of the conduct and the extent of its causal relation to the damages. Under KRS 411.182(3) the judgment states each party’s equitable share, which makes liability several rather than joint and several, so no single defendant can be made to pay the entire award. Under KRS 411.182(4) releasing one party reduces the remaining claim by that party’s share. Every responsible party has to be identified and named or its percentage is simply lost.
If the crash was fatal, KRS 411.130(1) requires the action to be prosecuted by the personal representative of the deceased rather than by a relative individually, and permits punitive damages if the act was willful or the negligence gross. Punitive damages have a separate statutory gate: KRS 411.184(2) requires clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud or malice as the statute defines those terms, and KRS 411.184(3) bars punitive damages against an employer for an employee’s act unless the employer authorized or ratified the conduct or should have anticipated it. And the deadline is short: under KRS 304.39-230(6), a motor vehicle tort action must generally be commenced not later than two years after the injury or the death, or after the date of issuance of the last basic or added reparation payment, whichever occurs later.
Why This Matters Most to Riders and Pedestrians
The people with the least between them and a trailer’s wheels are the ones with the least protection, since no standard requires a barrier along the side of a trailer at all. Our pages on bicycle accidents and motorcycle accidents cover the added dangers riders face around large trucks.
Kentucky law also treats these victims differently, and in their favor. Under KRS 304.39-060(2)(c), the no fault tort limitations do not apply at all to a person who is not an owner, operator, maintainer or user of a motor vehicle, such as a pedestrian or a bicyclist, nor to a motorcycle passenger. Everyone else has to clear the threshold in KRS 304.39-060(2)(b), which requires medical expense exceeding $1,000 or an injury involving permanent disfigurement, a bone fracture, loss of a body member, permanent injury within reasonable medical probability, permanent loss of a bodily function, or death. An underride crash usually clears that threshold in the worst possible way.
Hurt by the Side of a Tractor Trailer in Kentucky?
A side underride case is unusual because the defendant will begin from a position of full compliance. There is no standard to violate, so the case has to be built on what the carrier and the manufacturer knew, what the industry has been told for years about what side guards can do, and what the trailer itself shows. That means the trailer, the wheels, the fairings and any aftermarket equipment have to be preserved before they are repaired, scrapped or put back in service. The Fleck Firm, PLLC was founded by attorney Tyler M. Fleck, a U.S. Army veteran who built his practice to serve people throughout Kentucky, including the freight corridors where these trailers run. If a crash with the side or rear of a commercial trailer hurt or killed someone in your family, we will move to preserve the trailer and any guard, pull the carrier’s inspection and maintenance file, get the personal representative appointed so a wrongful death claim can be filed properly, and tell you honestly what the evidence will and will not support. The first consultation is free and we work on a contingency fee, so there is no fee unless we win for you. Call (270) 446-7000, and if you cannot come to us we will come to you, including at the hospital or your home.








