Quick Answer
The strongest evidence on this subject is a published meta analysis rather than a headline. Chee JN, Rapoport MJ, Molnar F, and colleagues, Update on the Risk of Motor Vehicle Collision or Driving Impairment with Dementia: A Collaborative International Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis, American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 2017;25(12):1376 to 1390 pooled nine studies covering 378 people with dementia and 416 controls and found a relative risk of 10.77 of failing a performance based on road test, with a 95 percent confidence interval of 3.00 to 38.62. The same review found medium to large effects of dementia on driving ability and concluded that even mild stages of dementia place patients at substantially higher risk. It also found the evidence on actual crash rates inconsistent: one study reported a fourfold increase in collisions per 1,000 miles driven over three years while another found no statistically significant increase. In Kentucky, the mechanism for acting on a genuinely unsafe driver is the medical review board under KRS 186.444, and it is condition based rather than age based.
Being older does not make a driver dangerous. What increases with age is the chance of developing a condition that impairs driving, and ignoring that does not make it go away. The distinction is the whole subject of this page: the licensing question asks whether a person is currently able to drive safely, and the injury question asks what a driver actually did on a particular day. They are answered by different bodies, on different evidence, and confusing them helps nobody.
If a cognitively impaired driver injures you, at any age, the claim is proved the same way as any other. KRS 189.290(1) requires the operator of any vehicle upon a highway to operate it in a careful manner, with regard for the safety and convenience of pedestrians and other vehicles, and KRS 189.290(4) prohibits operating any vehicle in a reckless or negligent manner so as to endanger persons or property. Where a specific statute was broken, KRS 446.070 allows a person injured by that violation to recover the damages sustained by reason of it, although a penalty is also imposed.
What is Cognitive Impairment?
Take the definition from a source that can be checked. MedlinePlus, published by the National Library of Medicine, describes dementia as a loss of mental functions severe enough to affect a person’s daily life and activities, and identifies causes including Alzheimer’s disease, Lewy body dementia, frontotemporal disorders and vascular dementia caused by stroke or hardening of the arteries. It also makes the point that matters most here: it is normal to become somewhat more forgetful with age, but dementia is not a normal part of aging. It is a serious disorder that interferes with daily life.
Cognitive impairment is broader than dementia and it runs from mild to severe. A person may struggle with:
- Remembering things
- Paying attention
- Speaking or understanding
- Recognising people, places or things
- Coping with an unfamiliar place or situation
Any of those can affect driving. A driver who cannot hold attention, who does not remember where he is going, or who cannot recognise where he is becomes distracted and stressed at exactly the moments that require neither.
Address the Issue Before It Becomes a Problem
If you are older and worried that you are having difficulty driving responsibly, talk to your family and to your physician. It is better to deal with the question before a crash than after one, and some of the causes are treatable. You may be able to drive safely in limited circumstances, such as daylight only, or by avoiding particular roads.
Understand that self limiting is a personal decision rather than a licensing category. Kentucky does issue a licence restricted to daytime driving, but under KRS 186.579(1) that restriction belongs to the bioptic telescopic device programme, imposed on a vision specialist’s recommendation or after failing a night examination under KRS 186.578, and it carries an annual comprehensive visual examination requirement under KRS 186.579(3)(b). Choosing not to drive at night is sensible; it is not a restriction unless one has been issued.
What the Research Actually Establishes
The 2017 international review described above is the most useful thing on this subject for a family trying to make a decision, and it is worth separating its three findings because they do not all point the same way.
First, driving performance. Pooling nine studies, the review found people with dementia were dramatically more likely to fail a performance based on road test, with a relative risk of 10.77 and a confidence interval running from 3.00 to 38.62, and it reported no significant variability across the studies on that point. That is a large, consistent effect.
Second, severity. The review concluded that even mild stages of dementia place patients at substantially higher risk of both failing a road test and demonstrating impaired driving performance. A diagnosis described as mild is not reassurance.
Third, and this is the finding the original version of this page omitted, actual crash rates. The evidence there was inconsistent. One included study reported a fourfold increase in motor vehicle collisions per 1,000 miles driven over three years; another found no statistically significant increase. That inconsistency is real and it should be stated, because a road test measures capability under observation while a crash rate measures what happens when people with a diagnosis adjust how much and where they drive.
Two claims that appeared on this page previously have been removed because they could not be verified. A study of older adults in a single Texas county was cited for the propositions that 61.4 percent of those found cognitively impaired still drove and that about a third of their caregivers had raised concerns, and that account was available only as a university press release rather than as a paper we could open and read. A prevalence figure of 6.7 million Americans aged 65 and older living with Alzheimer’s, and the framing of about one in nine, also came from a source we could not open. Neither the percentages nor the prevalence count appears here now. The title of this page previously asserted that a study estimated the majority of drivers older than 65 are cognitively impaired, which is not what any study we could verify says and is not even what the deleted press release said, so the title was corrected as well.
Raising Concerns With the Driver May Not Be Enough
Conversations about driving are hard. The driver fears losing autonomy and may be embarrassed about decline. Starting early, while the person can fully participate in the discussion, is better than starting late. But an open, honest and kind conversation may still end with the keys where they were. The person may not recognise the risk, whether from stubbornness, fear of losing freedom, or the impairment itself. Many people also treat driving as a right when it is a privilege that can be restricted.
Kentucky has a formal process for that situation, and the details matter because people get them wrong. Under KRS 186.444(1), a medical review board receives cases relating to the ability of an applicant or holder of a motor vehicle operator’s license to drive due to physical or mental disability which may affect or limit the person’s ability to operate a motor vehicle safely. Under KRS 186.444(2) the secretary of the Transportation Cabinet appoints physicians, osteopaths, optometrists or advanced practice registered nurses to the board, and one member licensed in the area relevant to the case must be present to conduct an informal hearing. The board is directed to use reasonable efforts to minimise the costs to the person under review. The Kentucky Medical Review Board programme page describes the board as medical professionals appointed by the secretary and cites KRS 186.444, KRS 186.411, KRS 186.577 and administrative regulations 601 KAR 13:090, 601 KAR 13:100 and 601 KAR 12:120 as its authority. That page also states that a person with a seizure condition must be free of seizures for ninety days to obtain or maintain driving privileges, and that after a report the driver is notified, medical forms are sent for the driver’s physician to complete, and the board notifies the driver of its decision within roughly twenty business days.
The form is TC 94-182, the Medical Review Affidavit, and the official form instructions say three things worth knowing before you fill it in:
- It is completed by a witness or witnesses of unsafe driving behaviours that could be attributed to certain medical conditions and affect the person’s ability to operate a motor vehicle. It is a report of observed driving, not a diagnosis
- If two citizens are completing the form, each must sign the affidavit and have it notarised
- The form is not confidential, and the subject driver has legal authority to request a copy of it. Whoever signs should expect the driver to learn who signed
What happens next is set out in the statute rather than left to discretion. Under KRS 186.444(3) the board’s forms include a signed sworn statement affirming that the person has a physical or mental condition that could impair the ability to operate a motor vehicle, along with the medical standards and the hearing procedures. Under KRS 186.444(4) the person under review may request a copy of the report alleging the condition in writing. Under KRS 186.444(5), if the cabinet decides to restrict driving privileges it must give written notice and must inform the person that the action will take place unless the person submits to and completes an examination satisfying the medical standards in regulation. Under KRS 186.444(6) the cabinet must consult appointed board members licensed in the relevant area before taking action based on a physical or mental condition where the person could not satisfactorily complete that examination, and under KRS 186.444(7) the person may request an informal hearing before the board.
Two provisions are the ones families least expect. Under KRS 186.444(8), a properly submitted report from the person’s own licensed medical professional, certifying on the board’s standards and the vision standards in KRS 186.577 that the person does not have a condition impairing the ability to drive, may supersede the medical review board, and the person may be approved to drive unless other conditions exist. And under KRS 186.444(9) the cabinet may not create tests or criteria for the purpose of limiting a licence because a person may be considered too old to drive. There is no age trigger in this process. There is a condition trigger, and a doctor’s certificate can end the inquiry. Under KRS 186.444(10) a person aggrieved by an informal hearing decision may appeal, and an administrative hearing follows under KRS Chapter 13B.
If the person is a friend or family member, filing may strain or end the relationship, and because the affidavit is not confidential you should assume they will know. That is a real cost and it deserves to be stated plainly rather than argued away. It is also worth being clear about what Kentucky law does not do: we could not locate any Kentucky statute imposing a legal duty on a family member to take away another adult’s keys, and none is asserted here. Nor could we verify any Kentucky requirement that a physician report an unsafe driver. What does exist is narrower. KRS 189.530(1) provides that no person shall provide a motor vehicle to another to operate upon a highway knowing that the other person is in an intoxicated condition or under the influence of any substance which may impair driving ability. That reaches intoxication and impairing substances. It does not address dementia, and it should not be cited as though it did.
How a Claim Against an Impaired Driver Is Actually Proved
The article this page replaces said the law gives no pass or favourable treatment to a driver who is elderly or cognitively impaired. We are not going to state that as a rule, because how Kentucky courts treat a defendant’s mental incapacity in a negligence case is a question of case law we did not have access to in preparing this page. What can be said from the statutes is more useful anyway.
The duty is the ordinary care duty in KRS 189.290(1), and it does not have a separate version for impaired drivers. The specific rules that decide most of these crashes are in KRS 189.330: subsection (4) at a stop sign, subsection (5) at a yield sign, subsection (9) on a left turn across oncoming traffic, and subsection (10) on entering or crossing a roadway from a driveway or parking lot. A driver who drifted through a stop sign broke KRS 189.330(4) whether or not the reason was a diagnosis, and KRS 446.070 supplies the civil remedy for the violation subject to proving that it caused the harm.
Fault gets apportioned. Under KRS 411.182 the fact finder assigns each party a percentage of the total fault, considering the nature of the conduct and how closely it is connected to the damages, and each party is liable only for its own equitable share, so nobody can be made to pay another party’s share. Recovery is shaped by KRS 304.39-060(2)(b), which allows pain and suffering only where medical expense exceeds $1,000 or the injury involves permanent disfigurement, a bone fracture, loss of a body member, permanent injury within reasonable medical probability, permanent loss of a bodily function, or death, while KRS 304.39-060(2)(c) removes those limits entirely for a person who is not an owner, operator, maintainer or user of a motor vehicle, such as a pedestrian.
The deadline is the motor vehicle deadline. Under KRS 304.39-230(6) an action must be commenced not later than two years after the injury, the death, or the date of issuance of the last basic or added reparation payment, whichever occurs later. If the crash was fatal, KRS 411.130(1) requires the wrongful death action to be prosecuted by the personal representative of the deceased rather than by a spouse or child individually, and it also permits punitive damages where the act was willful or the negligence gross. On punitive damages generally, KRS 411.184(2) permits an award only on clear and convincing evidence that the defendant acted toward the plaintiff with oppression, fraud or malice, each defined in the statute. A diagnosis does not meet that standard, and neither does a family’s failure to act.
Injured by a Driver Whose Family Already Knew?
The hardest version of this case is the one where somebody saw it coming. A daughter had already taken the car keys once. A neighbour had already stopped letting the grandchildren ride along. A physician had already raised it. None of that is in the crash report, and none of it surfaces unless somebody asks the right people in the first few months. The Fleck Firm, PLLC was founded by attorney Tyler M. Fleck, a U.S. Army veteran who built his practice to serve people throughout Kentucky. If a driver injured you or someone in your family, we will start with what the driver actually did at that intersection and which provision of KRS Chapter 189 it broke, find out whether the Transportation Cabinet already had a file, identify every policy and every owner who may answer for the vehicle, and protect the two year deadline in KRS 304.39-230(6). We will also tell you which parts of this cannot be established, because a claim built on a diagnosis rather than on driving conduct is a claim that fails. The first consultation is free and we work on a contingency fee, so there is no fee unless we win for you. Call (270) 446-7000, and if you cannot come to us we will come to you, including at the hospital or your home.








