You did the responsible thing and bought insurance. Then a driver with no coverage, or with only the state minimum, hit you, and that driver’s insurance ran out long before your medical bills did. At that point, the policy you paid for becomes the most important source of recovery. The awkward part is that the company you now need to pay you fairly is your own insurer, and its claims department will evaluate your injuries the same way it would evaluate a stranger’s.
The Fleck Firm, PLLC represents Elizabethtown and Hardin County drivers, passengers and pedestrians in uninsured motorist (UM) and underinsured motorist (UIM) claims. We read the policy, follow the notice rules, document the full value of the claim, and push back when an insurer delays or underpays. Attorney Tyler M. Fleck is a U.S. Army veteran who served as an attorney and officer in the Army JAG Corps and has had years of specialized trial training.
The first consultation is free. We work on contingency, so you pay no attorney’s fee unless we recover money for you.
How UM and UIM Coverage Works in Kentucky
UM and UIM are two different coverages under Kentucky law. They respond to different problems and are required in different ways.
| Uninsured motorist (UM) | Underinsured motorist (UIM) | |
| When it applies | The at-fault driver has no liability insurance, or in some situations cannot be identified | The at-fault driver has insurance, but not enough to cover your damages |
| Kentucky statute | KRS 304.20-020 | KRS 304.39-320 |
| Is it in your policy? | Required, at least at the state minimum limits, unless a named insured rejected it in writing | Only if it was requested. Insurers must make it available upon request |
| Common trap | A written rejection signed years ago still applies to every insured on the policy and to later renewals | Many drivers never asked for UIM coverage and do not have it |
Kentucky’s UM statute also treats some insured vehicles as uninsured. That includes a vehicle whose insurer becomes insolvent, a vehicle with less than the minimum required limits, and a vehicle whose own insurer denies coverage.
UIM coverage works differently. Kentucky defines an underinsured motorist as a driver whose liability coverage is less than a judgment recovered against that driver. In practice, UIM pays the part of your damages above the at-fault driver’s liability limits, up to your UIM limits.
Other attorneys take contingent fees of 33% to 50% of your settlement.
We want you to keep more of your money.
Our contingent fee is only 30% on cases settled prior to filing suit.
Why this matters in Hardin County
Kentucky’s minimum liability limits are only $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury. A single surgery, a short hospital stay or several months of lost wages can exceed $25,000. On busy roads like US 31W, Ring Road and Interstate 65, many drivers carry only minimum limits, so underinsured claims are common. Our article on how car insurance works in Kentucky explains the rest of the coverage structure, including PIP, and our post on why vehicle insurance costs what it does covers the pricing side.
Stacking and Policy Limits
If your household insures more than one vehicle, the amount of UM or UIM coverage available may be larger than the number shown for a single vehicle. Kentucky courts have repeatedly addressed “stacking,” which means combining coverage from more than one vehicle.
- UM stacking. In Chaffin v. Kentucky Farm Bureau (1990), the Kentucky Supreme Court refused to enforce an anti-stacking clause when separate premiums were paid for UM coverage on separate vehicles. The court relied on the personal nature of UM coverage and on the reasonable expectation that separate premiums buy separate coverage.
- UIM stacking. In Allstate v. Dicke (1993), the Court applied similar reasoning to underinsured motorist coverage and held that an anti-stacking provision was void as against public policy.
- Guest passengers are treated differently. In James v. James (2000), the Court held that a guest passenger who does not live in the vehicle owner’s household cannot stack UIM coverage from all of the owner’s vehicles. That passenger is generally limited to the coverage on the vehicle involved in the crash.
Stacking questions turn on the policy wording, the premium charges shown on the declarations page, and who qualifies as an insured. We get the complete policy and each declarations page before calculating the coverage available.
Other limits that affect the claim
- Per-person and per-accident caps. If several people were hurt, they may share a per-accident limit.
- Offsets and credits. A UIM insurer is generally credited with the at-fault driver’s liability limits, and the policy may contain other offsets that Kentucky law allows.
- Household and employer policies. You may have coverage under a policy owned by a relative in your household. If you were driving for work, coverage may also exist under the employer’s policy.
When Your Own Insurer Fights You
In a UM or UIM claim, your insurer takes the position the at-fault driver would take. It can dispute fault, argue that your injuries were preexisting, question your treatment, and offer less than the claim is worth. Paying premiums does not change that dynamic.
Free Consultation
Contact us today for a free consultation to see how we can put our years of experience to work for you.
The UIM settlement notice rule
The most technical part of a UIM claim comes when the at-fault driver’s insurer offers to settle. Under KRS 304.39-320, if that settlement would leave you with an underinsured claim, you must send written notice of the proposed settlement by certified or registered mail to every UIM insurer that provides coverage. The UIM insurer then has 30 days to choose one of two paths:
- Consent to the settlement, or fail to respond as the statute requires. You may then release the at-fault driver and the driver’s insurer and finalize the settlement without harming your UIM claim.
- Refuse consent to preserve its subrogation rights. To do that, the UIM insurer must pay you the amount of the liability insurer’s written offer within 30 days after receiving notice. The UIM insurer can then pursue the at-fault driver and the driver’s liability insurer for that payment.
This procedure grew out of the Kentucky Supreme Court’s decision in Coots v. Allstate (1993) and is now written into the statute. Sending notice the wrong way or releasing the at-fault driver too early can damage the UIM claim.
The 2024 change on settling below the limits
A 2024 amendment, which applies to policies issued or renewed on or after April 2, 2024, lets an injured person settle with the at-fault driver for less than that driver’s full liability limits. The tradeoff is significant: the UIM insurer still receives a credit for the full liability limits, even if the settlement was for less. There is a narrow exception when the full limits are divided among several injured people based on a reasonable pro rata settlement. Before accepting any offer below policy limits, you should calculate exactly how that credit will affect the UIM claim.
Bad Faith Claims
Kentucky does not allow an insurer to drag out or lowball a valid claim without consequences. The Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act, KRS 304.12-230, lists prohibited practices that frequently arise in UM and UIM claims, including:
- Failing to acknowledge and respond reasonably promptly to claim communications
- Refusing to pay a claim without a reasonable investigation based on all available information
- Failing to attempt in good faith to settle promptly and fairly when liability has become reasonably clear
- Forcing insureds to sue by offering substantially less than the amount they ultimately recover
- Failing to give a reasonable explanation for denying a claim or making a compromise offer
What a bad faith claim requires
Under Wittmer v. Jones (1993), a bad faith claim requires proof of three things:
- The insurer was obligated to pay the claim under the policy.
- The insurer lacked a reasonable basis in law or fact for denying it.
- The insurer knew it had no reasonable basis, or acted with reckless disregard for whether a reasonable basis existed.
A low offer alone is not bad faith. An insurer is generally entitled to contest a claim that is fairly debatable on the law or the facts. But delay, an inadequate investigation, ignored records, or unexplained changes in position can support a bad faith claim, so we document every step.
Interest and attorney’s fees
Under KRS 304.12-235, claims under an insurance contract must be paid within 30 days after the insurer receives notice and proof of claim in the form the policy requires. If the insurer does not make a good faith attempt to settle in that period, the final settlement bears interest at 12% per year. If the delay was without reasonable foundation, the insured is entitled to reasonable attorney’s fees. You can also file a written complaint with the Kentucky Department of Insurance, which publishes instructions for filing a consumer complaint.
Recovering the Full Value of Your Claim
A UM or UIM claim is only as strong as the proof behind it. Your insurer will not volunteer future losses you have not documented. Our process is designed to show the full picture:
- Coverage first. We collect every policy that may apply, including household policies, a rideshare or employer policy, and the at-fault driver’s liability coverage.
- Liability proof. In a UM or UIM claim, you still must show the other driver was at fault. We gather the crash report, photographs, witness statements and vehicle data, just as we would in a claim against that driver directly.
- Medical documentation. We obtain complete records and, when needed, opinions from treating physicians about future care, permanency and work restrictions.
- Economic losses. That includes wage records, lost benefits, and any reduction in your ability to earn in the future.
- Human losses. Pain, limitations, sleep problems, missed family events and the loss of things you used to enjoy are real damages. A short journal and statements from family members can help prove them.
- Timing. UM and UIM claims are contract claims, and many policies impose their own notice and filing requirements. A claim against the at-fault driver also has a two-year deadline under Kentucky’s motor vehicle statute. We identify every deadline early.
Negotiation, lawsuits and fees
Most claims are resolved through negotiation, and our article on whether injury claims usually settle before a lawsuit is filed explains how that process usually works. If your insurer will not offer a fair amount, we can file suit and present the claim to a jury.
Our contingency fee is 30% on cases settled before a lawsuit is filed. That means more of the recovery stays with you. Learn more about our founder on Tyler Fleck’s attorney page, or see how we handle crash cases generally on our Elizabethtown car accident page.
Checking Your Coverage Before the Next Crash
Most people first read their UM and UIM coverage after a crash, when it is too late to change it. A ten-minute review now can make a large difference later:
- Find out whether anyone rejected UM coverage. A written rejection signed by any named insured applies to everyone on the policy and carries forward to renewals unless someone later requests the coverage in writing.
- Ask for UIM coverage in writing if you do not have it. Because Kentucky insurers only have to make UIM coverage available on request, it is easy to go years without it.
- Match your UM and UIM limits to your own liability limits. Minimum-limit UM coverage protects you only to the same $25,000 per person floor the law requires of other drivers.
- Look at the premium charges on each vehicle. Separate UM or UIM premiums on separate vehicles are often what determines whether coverage can be stacked.
Fort Knox families have one more protection worth knowing. Under KRS 304.20-0411, an insurer may not refuse to issue a motor vehicle liability policy, or charge an extra premium, solely because a person was uninsured while on military service and away from Kentucky. A service member returning from an assignment outside the state should not be penalized for that gap when buying coverage again.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will filing a UM or UIM claim raise my rates?
Insurers have their own rating practices, and we cannot speak for any particular company. A claim caused by another driver’s fault is a different situation from an at-fault crash, and your policy gives you a contractual right to make the claim you paid for.
Can I make a UIM claim if I accepted the other driver’s policy limits?
Possibly, but only if you followed the notice procedure in KRS 304.39-320 before releasing the at-fault driver. Signing a release first can jeopardize the UIM claim, so get advice before signing.
Do I have UIM coverage?
Check your declarations page. Kentucky insurers must offer UIM coverage on request, but it is not included automatically the way UM coverage is unless rejected. We can review the declarations page with you.
Does UM coverage apply if I was walking or riding a bike?
Often, yes. The Kentucky Supreme Court has described UM coverage as personal to the insured rather than tied only to a particular vehicle, so it can apply when an insured is hit while walking or cycling. The policy language controls who counts as an insured.
Talk to an Elizabethtown Uninsured Motorist Lawyer
You paid for this coverage so you would be protected when another driver could not pay for the harm. We can help make sure your insurer honors that promise. Contact The Fleck Firm for a free consultation about a UM or UIM claim in Elizabethtown, Radcliff, Fort Knox or anywhere in Hardin County. We will review your policy, identify the deadlines, and explain how much coverage may be available.



