Quick Answer
In Kentucky you can still pursue a claim when you were partly at fault for a crash. Fault is divided by percentage rather than used as an on or off switch. Under KRS 411.182(1) and (2), the fact finder assigns a percentage of the total fault to each claimant, defendant and third party defendant, considering both the nature of each party’s conduct and the extent of the causal relation between that conduct and the damages claimed. Your share reduces your recovery, so if your damages total one hundred thousand dollars and the other driver is sixty percent responsible, the other driver’s share of your damages is sixty thousand dollars. Two things follow that surprise people. Under KRS 411.182(3) each party owes only its equitable share, so you cannot collect the whole award from whichever defendant is easiest to reach. And your own medical bills and lost wages can be paid regardless of fault, because KRS 304.39-030(1) gives every person injured in a Kentucky crash a right to basic reparation benefits. Because the percentages decide the money, insurers fight hard over them, which is why the investigation matters.
If I’m Partly at Fault, Can I File a Car Accident Lawsuit?
In Kentucky, as long as you are not entirely at fault for a crash, you can bring a claim against the others who share the blame. Your damages, meaning the harm you suffered measured in dollars, will be reduced by your share. Depending on the circumstances, working out who is how much at fault can be the most important part of the whole case.
It is worth being precise about where that rule comes from, because a great many articles get it wrong. Kentucky’s move away from the old rule, under which any fault of your own barred recovery completely, came from decisions of the Kentucky Supreme Court rather than from a statute. What the statute supplies is the machinery. KRS 411.182(1) requires the court, in all tort actions involving fault of more than one party, to make findings indicating the amount of damages each claimant would be entitled to absent comparative fault and the percentage of the total fault of all parties allocated to each claimant, defendant and third party defendant. KRS 411.182(2) tells the fact finder what to weigh in setting those percentages: the nature of the conduct of each party at fault and the extent of the causal relation between the conduct and the damages claimed.
So the statute does not say you lose if you are more than half to blame, and it does not say you lose if you are one percent to blame. It says the fault gets allocated and the numbers do the rest.
Negligence Law is the Basis for Accident Claims
The legal theory of negligence is the basis for nearly all car accident cases, in which you, the injured party or plaintiff, make a claim against the responsible party, the defendant, for the harm done. Where the responsible party has insurance covering the crash, that insurer normally pays for a legal defense and for any settlement or judgment within the policy limits.
The exception is where the other driver struck your vehicle on purpose, which happens in road rage and domestic violence situations. Because there was no accident in the ordinary sense, an insurer may take the position that the policy does not cover it, and whether it does turns on the wording of the particular policy rather than on a general rule.
There may be multiple defendants where more than one party is to blame.
- You may have been hurt in a multi vehicle crash on a highway or at an intersection
- A commercial truck crash can involve several companies at fault. The truck may be owned by one company and maintained by another, or owned by one business while the driver works for another
- Where the crash happened may have been poorly designed, maintained or lit, which can put a government agency responsible for the road in the picture. A claim against a state or local government agency does not proceed like an ordinary lawsuit against a private party, so that route has to be identified early rather than discovered late
The plaintiff has the burden of proving:
- That the defendant owed the plaintiff a legal duty, which for a driver means driving reasonably in a reasonably safe vehicle
- That the defendant breached that duty, for example by driving too fast, driving distracted or driving while impaired
- That the breach was the factual and legal cause of the crash and of the injuries
- That the plaintiff suffered damages the defendant must pay for
In a Kentucky crash there is one more layer sitting on top of ordinary negligence law, and it decides whether part of your claim exists at all. Under KRS 304.39-060(2)(a), tort liability for bodily injury arising from the use of a motor vehicle in Kentucky is abolished to the extent basic reparation benefits are payable for it. Under KRS 304.39-060(2)(b), you may recover damages in tort for pain, suffering, mental anguish and inconvenience only where the benefits payable as medical expense exceed one thousand dollars, or the injury consists in whole or in part of permanent disfigurement, a fracture to a bone, a compound, comminuted, displaced or compressed fracture, loss of a body member, permanent injury within reasonable medical probability, permanent loss of bodily function or death. KRS 304.39-060(2)(c) provides that the limit does not apply to a person who is not an owner, operator, maintainer or user of a motor vehicle, such as a pedestrian, nor to the passenger of a motorcycle. And under KRS 304.39-060(4) and (7), a person who filed a written rejection of those tort limits with the Department of Insurance before the crash retains full tort rights.
The Greater Your Blame the Lower the Recovery
Comparative fault is the rule for splitting damages when more than one party is at fault. Where both drivers were negligent, the insurance company, judge or jury allocates responsibility as a percentage. Unless you are entirely to blame, you can recover the portion of your damages attributable to the other driver’s share of fault. If your total damages are one hundred thousand dollars and the other driver is sixty percent at fault, sixty thousand dollars is the other driver’s share.
Kentucky adds two rules to that arithmetic that change what the number is worth. KRS 411.182(3) requires the court to determine the award of damages to each claimant in accordance with the findings and to enter judgment against each party liable on the basis of the rules of joint and several liability, except that any party who is allocated less than one hundred percent of the total fault may not be held jointly liable for more than the amount of damages in proportion to the percentage of fault allocated to that party. In plain terms, liability is several, and each defendant pays its own share. If one of two responsible parties has no money and no insurance, that share can simply be uncollectible. KRS 411.182(4) then provides that a release given to one person liable in tort does not discharge the others, but reduces the claim against the others to the extent of the released person’s equitable share of the obligation, so taking an early check from one of several responsible parties can quietly reduce what is left to pursue.
Here is the part that matters most while you are still in treatment. Being partly at fault does not stop your own medical bills and lost wages from being paid in the meantime. Under KRS 304.39-030(1), if the accident causing injury occurs in Kentucky, every person suffering loss from injury arising out of the maintenance or use of a motor vehicle has a right to basic reparation benefits, unless they had rejected the limitation on their tort rights. Those benefits, which most people call PIP, are paid without regard to who caused the crash. KRS 304.39-020(2) caps them at ten thousand dollars for all economic loss per person per accident, and the current text of that statute took effect on July 15, 2026. Do not confuse that ten thousand dollar benefit with the one thousand dollar medical expense threshold described above. They are different numbers doing different jobs, and confusing them is one of the most common errors in writing about Kentucky crashes.
There is also one commonly assumed fault argument that Kentucky law addresses directly. KRS 189.125(5) provides that failure to use a child passenger restraint system or a child booster seat shall not be considered as contributory negligence, nor shall such failure be admissible as evidence in the trial of any civil action, and that failure of any person to wear a seat belt shall not constitute negligence per se. Read those two sentences separately, because they do different things. The child restraint rule is both a bar on the argument and a bar on the evidence. The adult seat belt rule says that not wearing one is not negligence in itself, which is not the same as saying the subject can never be mentioned. If an adjuster is discounting your claim because you were not belted, that is a conversation worth having with a lawyer rather than conceding.
When it comes to who ends up with how large a settlement or verdict, the devil is in the details. Depending on how serious your injuries are and what they do to your current and future income, a decision that you were twenty or thirty percent to blame can move the number substantially. The other value drivers are covered in why some personal injury cases are worth more than others, and the full list of what can be claimed is in what you can collect from a Kentucky personal injury case.
The Facts Should Show Who is How Much at Fault
How difficult that is depends on the circumstances. A driver can be found more to blame where he or she:
- Speeds
- Fails to yield the right of way
- Drives too fast for conditions
- Is distracted
- Is intoxicated, tired or asleep
- Suffers an illness or medical condition that makes driving unsafe
- Ignores stop signs, yield signs or traffic signals
- Rear ends the other vehicle
- Drives an unsafe vehicle
There are crashes where both drivers made serious mistakes, and crashes where both made small ones. Where fault is not clear cut, what shows the degree of each party’s responsibility? Insurance companies investigate crashes for their own purposes. Our office investigates our clients’ cases for theirs.
Where one is needed, we retain an engineer who reconstructs crashes. Working from the physical facts, that expert forms an opinion on how and why the crash happened, how the injuries were caused, and the degree to which each party was at fault. The expert prepares a report that can be used in negotiations and can testify if the case is litigated. The insurance company may have its own expert doing the same thing from the other direction.
An investigation can cover many factors, and in any given case one or two of them carry most of the weight. Every crash is different:
- The scene is visited, photographed and measured
- Photos or video taken just after the crash by the drivers or by police are reviewed
- Security and traffic camera video is obtained and reviewed
- The investigator drives the same routes the vehicles took, to understand what each driver could actually see
- Skid marks and physical damage to nearby objects such as guardrails or utility poles are examined
- The vehicles are examined to establish where the damage is and how severe it is
- Electronic data stored by a vehicle may show speed, direction, acceleration and braking
- Phone records and device data may show whether apps were open and whether the driver was talking or texting, along with route and speed
- Eyewitnesses and our client are interviewed
- Police reports and the evidence gathered by law enforcement are obtained and reviewed
- A driver may have made statements to police, to the other driver or on social media that admit fault or are otherwise damaging
- Whether a driver was cited or arrested is an indication of blame, although it is not the last word on civil fault
- Road condition, weather and visibility information is considered
- Medical records can be reviewed to show where and how much force reached the driver and passengers
Most of that evidence has a short life. Video is overwritten on rolling schedules, vehicles are repaired or scrapped, and event data can be lost. The percentage an insurer assigns to you in month six is often a function of what nobody collected in week one.
Why Representing Yourself is a Mistake
Car accident cases can be complex, and this one is complex in a specific way. You may feel the other driver is plainly at fault, and the insurer may come back with facts suggesting you contributed. What would you do in response?
Would you run your own investigation? Retain your own reconstruction expert? Negotiate a settlement around the finer points of each driver’s legal responsibilities, the one thousand dollar tort threshold, whether a seat belt argument is even permissible, and the effect on your remaining claim of releasing one of several defendants? You are better off with someone who has done this before and has helped clients in the same position.
The deadline is the other reason not to wait. Under KRS 304.39-230(6), a motor vehicle tort action must be commenced no later than two years after the injury or the death, or after the date of issuance of the last basic or added reparation payment, whichever occurs later. That is longer than the one year period that applies to most other Kentucky injury claims under KRS 413.140(1)(a), whose current text took effect on July 15, 2026, and it is a difference worth knowing rather than guessing at.
Being Blamed for a Kentucky Crash You Did Not Cause?
An adjuster’s percentage is an opening position, not a finding, and it is usually built from whatever evidence was easiest for the insurer to gather. The Fleck Firm, PLLC was founded by attorney Tyler M. Fleck, a U.S. Army veteran who built his practice to serve people throughout Kentucky. If you are being told that a crash was partly or mostly your fault, we will get the scene, the vehicle data and the video before they disappear, bring in a reconstruction engineer where the facts justify it, make sure your basic reparation benefits are being paid while the fault fight goes on, and push back on fault arguments that Kentucky law does not actually allow. The first consultation is free and we work on a contingency fee, so there is no fee unless we win for you. Call (270) 446-7000, and if you cannot come to us we will come to you, including at the hospital or your home.








