Quick Answer
Mediation is a dispute resolution process in which a neutral third person, the mediator, works with both sides to help them reach an agreement. In Kentucky it is not an informal custom. It is governed by rules the Supreme Court of Kentucky adopted as Civil Rules 99 and 100, effective February 1, 2022, which replaced the old Model Mediation Rules entirely. Those rules define what mediation is, who has to be in the room, who pays the mediator, and what is confidential. Under CR 99.02 the decision making authority stays with the parties and not with the mediator, so no one can be made to settle.
Mediators act like diplomats. They go back and forth between the parties, trying to move both toward a resolution each can accept. It works when both sides participate in good faith and understand that avoiding the risk of a trial is a goal worth pursuing. It is not magic, and it is not a hearing.
What is Mediation?
Kentucky defines it. CR 99.02 describes mediation as an informal process in which a neutral third person called a mediator facilitates the resolution of a dispute between two or more parties, designed to help them reach agreement on all or part of the issues in dispute, with decision making authority remaining with the parties. The mediator assists in identifying issues, fostering joint problem solving and exploring settlement alternatives.
In practice the mediator is usually an attorney, a former attorney or a retired judge. What matters most under the rules is not subject matter expertise. CR 100.02 states that a mediator’s most important qualification is competence in the procedural aspects of facilitating resolution rather than familiarity with technical knowledge about the dispute, and requires the mediator to obtain and keep up the necessary skills and substantive training.
The mediator has no stake in who gets what. CR 100.03 requires impartiality in word and action and requires the mediator, no later than the beginning of the first session, to disclose any known relationship with the parties or their counsel, any personal knowledge of the facts, and any economic interest in the outcome. If a party objects on impartiality grounds and continues to object after discussion, the mediator must decline or withdraw. CR 100.08(2) separately forbids a mediator from charging a contingent fee or a fee based on the outcome.
Both sides usually split the cost, and that is the default rule rather than a courtesy. Under CR 99.06 the mediator is paid at the rate agreed with the parties where the parties chose the mediator, and unless the parties agree otherwise or the court orders otherwise, the parties divide the mediator’s professional fees equally.
Choosing the mediator is the parties’ job first. CR 99.05 gives the parties fifteen days after a referral to agree on a mediator or a mediation service, and only if they cannot agree does the court select one. Mediation can be used at almost any stage of a civil dispute, and a referral does not pause anything: CR 99.04 provides that referral to mediation does not operate as a stay of discovery or other proceedings unless the court orders it or the parties agree in writing.
One more thing worth knowing about how a case gets there. CR 99.03 lets a court refer a case to mediation on its own motion or a party’s motion, but expressly forbids a blanket policy of sending all cases, or all cases of a particular type, to mediation, and forbids requiring mediation as a precondition to getting a trial date. The court is supposed to weigh the stage of the litigation, the nature of the issues, the value of confidentiality and speed, the parties’ willingness, prior attempts at resolution, the parties’ ability to participate including by video, and the cost.
What Happens at a Mediation?
How formal it feels depends on the mediator. Each has a style. Some are like sheepdogs, herding the parties toward an agreement and nudging them along. Others are more structured. Usually everyone starts together in a conference room, then the parties move into separate rooms and the mediator goes back and forth. CR 99.07 allows the mediator to confer with the parties or counsel before the conference, expressly permits those pre conference contacts to be one sided at the mediator’s discretion, and allows the mediator to require a confidential statement of the case in advance. Under CR 99.08(6) the whole thing can be virtual, or any single participant can appear by video, unless the parties agree otherwise or the court orders otherwise.
Who has to be there is where Kentucky’s rules matter most to an injured person, because it decides whether the person who can actually approve a number is in the building. Under CR 99.08(1) the parties and their counsel attend unless the court orders or the parties explicitly agree otherwise. Under CR 99.08(4), if a party is insured for the claim in dispute, that party must also have a representative of the insurance carrier present who is not the carrier’s outside counsel and who has full settlement authority, and the court may not stop that representative from calling for more authority. CR 99.08(5) defines full settlement authority as authority to negotiate on behalf of the party or carrier, and makes clear it does not mean authority to settle for any particular amount.
If a deal is reached, CR 99.10 requires it to be reduced to writing and signed by the parties at the conference. The parties are responsible for drafting it, although the mediator may help if everyone consents. Do not leave a mediation believing you have an agreement that nobody wrote down.
What Should I Say at a Mediation?
Confidentiality is real, and it is broader than most people expect, but it is not unlimited and the difference matters. CR 99.11(3) provides that mediation is regarded as settlement negotiations for purposes of KRE 408, which makes evidence of offering or accepting valuable consideration to compromise a disputed claim inadmissible to prove liability or the amount of the claim, and likewise excludes evidence of conduct or statements made in compromise negotiations. CR 99.11(4) goes further: all mediation communications, including documents, are both privileged and confidential, the mediation process includes communications with the mediator before, during and after the conference, and those communications are not subject to discovery and are not admissible in any judicial or administrative proceeding.
Here is the limit that catches people out. The same subsection says evidence that is otherwise admissible or discoverable is not made inadmissible or undiscoverable just because it was disclosed or used at the mediation. Handing a document to the other side across a mediation table does not put that document beyond reach. And under CR 99.11(11) an executed settlement document is not privileged unless the parties explicitly stipulate that the terms are confidential, and even then it loses the privilege if it has to be produced to enforce the settlement.
There is also a private channel. Under CR 99.11(6) it is your responsibility, and your lawyer’s, to tell the mediator precisely what you are saying in confidence, and under CR 99.11(7) the mediator cannot pass along anything told in confidence without your permission. Under CR 99.11(8) the mediator may not discuss anything from the mediation with court officials or staff or comment on the negotiations at all. The narrow exception is CR 99.11(10), which allows a mediator to report abuse under KRS 209.030, KRS 620.030 or other applicable law.
Personal injury cases involve someone who was hurt and someone who may be responsible because they made a mistake. We all make mistakes, and mediation can help both sides put it behind them, financially and emotionally. Plaintiffs are often angry, and with reason. Defendants often feel unfairly accused and see the claim as an attempt to profit. The confidentiality rules exist precisely so that both of those things can be said out loud without either one becoming evidence.
What’s the Bottom Line?
A personal injury settlement comes down to money. What will the plaintiff accept to bring the matter to an end, and what will the insurance company pay? The demand has to be defensible on the facts. We do not pull figures out of the air, because that is not good faith negotiation and it hardens the other side.
Insurance companies retain outside counsel or use their own lawyers to defend their insureds, and the carrier is the entity writing the check, so the insured individual usually has little say in the number. That is also why CR 99.08(4) puts a carrier representative with full settlement authority in the room.
If more than one defendant is at the table, there is a Kentucky rule that has to be part of the arithmetic before you accept anything. Under KRS 411.182(3) each party is liable only for its own equitable share of the obligation, and under KRS 411.182(4) a release given to one party reduces your claim against the remaining parties by that released party’s equitable share. Settling with one defendant at mediation does not shift its share to the others. Taking an early number from the easiest defendant can cost you more than it pays.
The mediator is not there to tell you what your case is worth. CR 100.06(3) provides that a mediator shall not impose an opinion about the merits of the dispute or about the acceptability of any proposed settlement option, although on request the mediator may offer evaluative observations. CR 100.07 confines the mediator to the role of mediator and forbids giving legal or other professional advice during the mediation. The person advising you at a mediation is your own lawyer.
What Happens if We Don’t Settle?
No one is required to settle. CR 100.06(1) requires the mediator to respect and encourage self determination by the parties in deciding whether, and on what terms, to resolve the dispute, and to refrain from being directive or judgmental about the issues and the settlement options. Often progress is made but time runs out and the session ends. The attorneys and the parties may take it from there and reach an agreement on their own, or everyone may reconvene with the mediator.
The court does get told something, but not what you said. Under CR 99.09, if the case settles the attorneys promptly notify the court and submit an order reflecting the settlement; if some issues settle, the parties file a joint statement within ten days listing what is resolved and what remains; and at the conclusion the attorneys report in writing that the process has ended, including reporting the lack of an agreement. The mediator does not report on the negotiations.
Mediation can also make the reality of a trial much sharper. You may get a defense verdict and recover nothing. Even a verdict in your favor may put a number on your damages well below what you hoped for. Those outcomes can be worse than a settlement offer that does not excite you, and accepting the offer may be the better decision. That judgment belongs to you, and the point of a mediation is to make sure you are making it with the risks in front of you rather than behind you.
Facing a Mediation in Your Kentucky Injury Case?
A mediation is a day when the decision is genuinely yours, which is exactly why it should not be the first day you learn what your file contains. The Fleck Firm, PLLC was founded by attorney Tyler M. Fleck, a U.S. Army veteran who built his practice to serve people throughout Kentucky. If your car accident case is heading to mediation, we will prepare the demand on the evidence rather than on a wish, make sure the carrier sends someone with real settlement authority as CR 99.08 requires, tell you what a release will do to any claim you still have against another defendant, and give you our honest read on what a jury might do with the same facts. We will not tell you what to accept, because under Kentucky’s rules and under any decent understanding of this work, that decision is yours. The first consultation is free and we work on a contingency fee, so there is no fee unless we win for you. Call (270) 446-7000, and if you cannot come to us we will come to you, including at the hospital or your home.








